A lot of tyre choice is personal. The rest is down to availability, riding conditions, cost.
The same question put to Devon TRF members has the following answers:-
A round one
Pirelli MT43 or Mitas ET01 on the rear (mitas ET01 is a softer compound, similar tread pattern with better side grip but not really suitable for the larger trailie unless you don't mind buying lots) and I run a Mitas EF08 road legal enduro front.
MT43 or similar trials tyre on the rear - I have a Michelin X11 trials rear but only because it was lying around and needed using. Will go to an MT43 next time - brilliant on wet and dry rocks and personally I don't find it any worse in mud than an enduro tyre if you keep a steady throttle hand.
Any enduro front tyre will do - I guess regular enduro Gods will notice a difference but I still have the original MT320 Pirelli front which should be terrible (the rear was) but doesn't feel any worse than a new Michelin Comp III. Experiment with pressures - I use Oki puncture preventative in the tubes and run 12psi but used 15-17psi before that. Some go as low as 8psi in wet mud....watch out for squirming on the road though. Rears - I switch between a MT43 and a Maxxis intermediate. I have to admit that on our east Devon lanes (last week) my bike was handling better with the Maxxis than with the Mt43. The 43 is past it's best though it must be said. When I've squeezed the last life out of it I'm not 100% I'll get another. I've talked to a few people regarding tyre recently and the consensus seems to be if you ride south Devon/Cornwall area the go MT43 but for out east the ground's a little softer and you may benefit from a slightly more aggressive profile. Also the bike itself may be more suited to different tyre sizes and styles. I once bought a used oversized Michelin Comp3 tyre from a guy with a KDX220 as this tyre was proving to be too much for the engine - I think it was 120/90 so bare that in mind if you were think of up sizing. I'm fancying the Maxxis M6001 Intermediate Terrain tyre next or maybe the Desert tyres. The Maxxcross Desert IT is specially designed compound increases durability in rocky or desert conditions by reducing chipping and cutting. * Stiffer carcass design minimizes flex, reducing the chance of pinched tubes * Tall knob design improves traction when racing in sandy conditions Problem is I suspect all the good tyres are not road approved - something to check first.
So, you can see that a lot of suggestions - still leaving you with a quandary.